Qualitative comparative analysis, necessary conditions. Ragin has been at the forefront of the development of innovative methods for social scientists. Fuzzy sets and beyond 2008 fuzzy set social science 2000. Set theoretic methods for the social sciences a guide to qualitative comparative analysis qualitative comparative analysis qca and other set theoretic methods distinguish themselves from other approaches to the study of social phenomena by using sets and the search for set relations. The unity and diversity of method sociology for a new.
Using data on hightechnology firms, i empirically investigate configurations. In that book he lays out methods for detecting necessary andor sucient conditions for social phenomena. A short introduction to qualitative comparative analysis. The present research implements both sem eqs is one of the most widely used sem programs and fsqca for the. Schneider, cq and rohlfing, i 2016 case studies nested in fuzzyset qca on sufficiency. Stokkes 10 cases involve cod stocks in the barents sea and the north west atlantic and. Market research further reading chapter 1 castell, s. Ragin find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. In this innovative approach to the practice of social sciencecharles ragin explores the use of fuzzy sets to bridge the divide between quantitive and qualitative methods. Making causal claims is central to evaluation practice because we want to know the effects of a program, project, or policy.
Numerical values were initially obtained by ragin for o survival of democracy, which was assumed to be the complement 19 of breakdown of democracy. Redesigning social inquiry provides a substantive critique of the standard approach to social researchnamely, assessing the relative importance of causal variables drawn from competing theories. Sets are central to social scientific discourse many, if not most, social scientific statements, especially empirical generalizations about. Critically, the second phase repositions the studys lens from the localized scale of the two researcherinresidence investigations to adopt a sector. The fuzzy conjoint analysis approach based on fuzzy set theory was used to analyze the data from twenty three mathematics teachers from four secondary schools in terengganu, malaysia. Rihoux and ragin 2009 have coined the term configurational comparative. The second trait shared by all settheoretic methods in the social sciences. The simplest form is the 2x2 table crosstabulating the presenceabsence of a cause against presenceabsence of an outcome. The unity and diversity of method sociology for a new century series kindle edition by ragin, charles c.
Qualitative comparative analysis and fuzzy sets charles c. The study provides critical tests of the usefulness of four alternative theories, proposed by hofstede, inglehart, schwartz, and steenkamp, of national cultures influences for explaining consumers. For researchers using software that does not support fuzzyset. Paradoxically, the fuzzy set is a powerful tool because it replaces an unwieldy, fuzzy instrumentthe variable, which establishes only the positions of cases relative to each other, with a precise onedegree of. Instead, ragin proposes the use of settheoretic methods to find a middle path between quantitative and qualitative research.
Based on several observations andor on some theoretical ideas, a social science researcher formulates a hypothesis that some property aimply some. Critically, the second phase repositions the studys lens from the localized scale of the two. This new analytic strategy is superior in several respects to the one sketched in fuzzy set social science ragin, 2000. Fuzzy sets qualitative comparative analysis uci school of social.
This means the concept is vague in some way, lacking a fixed, precise meaning, without however being unclear or meaningless altogether. This new analytic strategy is superior in several respects to the one sketched in fuzzyset social science ragin, 2000. The basic difference between crisp set and fuzzy set might generate a new thinking for using fuzzy tolls. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading redesigning social inquiry. Rooted in set theory and in ragins 2000 work on fuzzyset qualitative comparative analysis fsqca. Using knowledge and techniques from social science, numerical values were obtained for ae for 18 european countries that in table 1 are called 18 cases 118. Pdf on jan 1, 2008, bear braumoeller and others published fuzzyset social science. It has a definite meaning, which can be made more precise only through further elaboration. The unity and diversity of method, second edition is a concise, innovative text designed for research methods courses in the social sciences.
Fuzzy sets and beyond kindle edition by ragin, charles c download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. A fuzzy concept is a concept of which the boundaries of application can vary considerably according to context or conditions, instead of being fixed once and for all. Correlation is central to conventional quantitative social science. Here, i develop a novel theoretical perspective on causal core and periphery, which is based on how elements of a configuration are connected to outcomes. The second part is a relatively gentletoo gentle in my viewintroduction to. The first comprehensive introduction of fuzzy sets to the social sciences was offered by michael smithson 1987. He argues that fuzzy sets allow a far richer dialogue between ideas and evidence in social. The work reported is part of a larger ongoing project which is employing qca to compare these relations within two birth cohorts. Paradoxically, the fuzzy set is a powerful tool because it replaces an. In the second table all democracies with parliamentary systems survived, that is, they are a subset of those that. Redesigning social inquiry rdsi is the title of my forthcoming book, which attempts to transcend the debate between dsi and rsi by offering new analytic tools that bridge qualitative and quantitative research methods. Then enter the name part of your kindle email address below. Fundamental aspects of fuzzy logic for social research fuzzy analysis is based on set theorem of pure mathematics. In this innovative approach to the practice of social scien.
The paper explores the use of charles ragin s qualitative comparative analysis qca in both its crisp and fuzzy set versions in the study of the relations between social class origin, sex, ability and subsequent educational achievement. The study employed a fuzzy approach questionnaire which consists of six attributes for measuring mathematics teachers beliefs about mathematics. To those belonging to this set of potential readers, i highly recommend the book. These contributions should not be read as introductions to fuzzy set analysis see smithson 1987. Fuzzy sets and beyond 2008 fuzzyset social science 2000. With the publication of fuzzyset social science charles ragin has provided social scientists with an impressive set of new tools for the analysis of social and political behavior.
Download pdf fuzzy set social science free online new. Typologies are an important way of organizing the complex causeeffect relationships that are key building blocks of the strategy and organization literatures. The study provides critical tests of the usefulness of four alternative theories, proposed by hofstede, inglehart, schwartz, and steenkamp, of national cultures influences for explaining consumers consumption of international services. The first part of the course deals with fundamental issues that are essential for almost all social science research. Figure 3, reproduced from fuzzy set social science, plots fuzzy membership in the set scored well on exam against fuzzy membership in the set studied hard. International journal of social research methodology, 162, 165166. Critical tests of multiple theories of cultures consequences. Ragin argues that fuzzy sets allow a far richer dialogue between ideas and evidence in social.
Redesigning social inquiry for over twenty years charles c. Has charles ragins fuzzyset social science filled the void. Assessing the importance of necessary or sucient conditions. In redesigning social inquiry, he continues his campaign to revitalize the field, challenging major aspects of the conventional template for social science research while offering a clear alternative. Settheoretic methods for the social sciences a guide to qualitative comparative analysis qualitative comparative analysis qca and other settheoretic methods distinguish themselves from other approaches to the study of social phenomena by using sets and the search for set relations. Implications of the changing conversation about causality for. Andrew bennett, 1999 isa paper on causal inference in case studies. It is surprising to us that fuzzy sets are not used more often in social science, given that almost all. Applications of fuzzy set theory 9 9 fuzzy logic and approximate reasoning 141 9. They, like schneider and wagemann, discuss stokkes 2004, 2007 research on shaming as a strategy for improving international regimes impact on resource management.
Ragin has some important points to make and deserves to be paid careful attention by social scientists of both qualitative and quantitative traditions. Export performance as a function of market learning. While both approaches have strengths and weaknesses, the one presented here uses the truth table as the key analytic device. While identifying order in the complexity of social life is the. Pdf fuzzy sets and social research charles ragin and paul. For social research, usually we use basic statistical tools, scales, indices both for crosssectional and longitudinal study. Charles ragins fuzzy set qualitative comparative analysis. The lack of support for contradictions in fsqca limits the methods usefulness for conducting inductive research. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading constructing social research. Application of fuzzy logic in sociological research. Aug 14, 2000 paradoxically, the fuzzy set is a powerful tool because it replaces an unwieldy, fuzzy instrument the variable, which establishes only the positions of cases relative to each other with a precise one degree of membership in a welldefined set.
Paradoxically, the fuzzy set is a powerful tool because it replaces an unwieldy, fuzzy instrumentthe variable, which establishes only the positions of pdf cases relative to each other, with a precise onedegree of membership in a welldefined set. Moving beyond qualitative and quantitative strategies 1987 won the 1989 stein rokkan prize of the international social science council of unesco. Why ragins fuzzy techniques lead to successful social. In virtually all social science fields, statements about social. The second part is a relatively gentletoo gentle in my viewintroduction to fuzzy set theory as well as to some applications to social scientific problems that can be addressed with fst. For potential readers in the set of sociologists with little background in fuzzy sets and wanting to use this method rather immediately, it seems youll have to wait a bit longer. Duke university political science 330 research design. Paradoxically, the fuzzy set is a powerful tool because it replaces an unwieldy, fuzzy instrumentthe variable, which establishes only the positions of pdf cases. The primary goal of this book is to show unity within the diversity of activities called social research. In this innovative approach to the practice of social science, charles ragin explores the use of fuzzy sets to bridge the divide between quantitative and. Charles ragin, fuzzy set social science, introduction and chapters 1 and 4, pp. A brief description and need for justi cation typical social science questions.
Fuzzy set theoryand its applications, fourth edition. Ragin argues that fuzzy sets allow a far richer dialogue between ideas and evidence in. Download fuzzy set social science ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub. Users guide to fuzzysetqualitative comparative analysis 2. In this paper, i describe how to extend fsqca to accommodate contradictory conditions. The second row addresses the dul causal combination, and so on. In the past decade, the conversation about establishing causal claims ha. Fuzzy set social science download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl. What the study of census data, the study of one person at a time, monitoring todays events, or reconstruction of social life centuries ago all have in common is that regardless of their case material, they construct representations of social life through a dialogue of ideas theory and. The core principle is the idea of assessing the degree to which two series of values parallel each other across cases. Moving beyond qualitative and quantitative strategies. In redesigning social inquiry, he continues his campaign to revitalize the field, challenging major aspects of the conventional template for social science research while offering a clear. Redesigning social inquiry provides a substantive critique of the.
The unity and diversity of method, northwestern university, pine forge, thousand oaks, 1994, pp. Ragin and sonnett 2005 note that social phenomena are profoundly limited in their diversity, complicating social analysis. Based on several observations andor on some theoretical ideas, a social science researcher formulates a hypothesis that some property aimply some other property b. Paradoxically, the fuzzy set is a powerful tool because it replaces an unwieldy, fuzzy instrument the variable, which establishes only the positions of cases relative. In this innovative approach to the practice of social science, charles ragin explores the use of fuzzy sets to bridge the divide between quantitative and qualitative methods. Because in the social sciences it is unusual to find perfect setsubset of connections that can. Fuzzyset social science, ragin university of chicago press. For illustration of the subset principle in the fuzzy set analysis of causal sufficiency, consider two fuzzy sets relevant to students in a course. Paradoxically, the fuzzy set is a powerful tool because it replaces an unwieldy, fuzzy instrumentthe variable, which establishes only the positions of cases relative to each other, with a precise onedegree of membership in a welldefined set. Paradoxically, the fuzzy set is a powerful tool because it replaces an unwieldy, fuzzy instrument the variable, which establishes only the positions of cases relative to each other with a precise one degree of membership in a welldefined set.
710 890 569 478 114 764 523 8 776 650 1171 1422 113 1226 434 1431 1576 1617 333 398 381 814 177 1586 733 111 1170 1228 1181 911 672 121 1016 465 152 463 1454 1164